This web page was produced as an assignment for an undergraduate course at Davidson College.
Image Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons via the United States Department of Agriculture
THE RESEARCH
PROJECT
Harvard Medical School’s George Church, Ph.D. led a
team of
scientists in an attempt to remedy the problem of transmissible
retroviruses
with respect to transplantation of pig organs to humans
(xenotransplantation).
Church’s team specifically honed in on the porcine endogenous retrovirus
(PERV)
pol gene. The pol gene’s inability to be eliminated by “biosecure breeding” makes
it a reasonable target for inactivation through genomic manipulation.
Previous
studies have reduced the risk of PERV transmission to humans using such
strategies
as small interfering RNAs and vaccines with limited success.
Church’s team incorporated a different strategy,
making use
of the CRISPR-Cas9
RNA-guided nuclease system.
HYPOTHESIS OR
DISCOVERY SCIENCE?
Church’s team studied strategies attempting to
reduce/eliminate PERV transmission from pig organs to humans. They found
that
the strategies from prior studies resulted in low success rates. After
this
discovery, the team achieved genome-wide success using the CRISPR-Cas9
system.
(Yang et al., 2015)
GENOMIC TECHNOLOGY
The
researchers analyzed
publically available PERV and other endogenous retrovirus sequences and
determined
that there were 62 copies of PERVs in the PK15 cell line. They determined
this
using droplet
digital PCR. Afterwards, they used Sanger Sequencing to check the results
of their sequencing whilst looking for any insertions or deletions. They
then designed “two Cas9 guide RNAs (gRNAs)” that specifically
targeted the pol gene. They
thought
this would be effective because the product of the pol gene acts as reverse transcriptase (RT), making it vital in
processes such as replication or viral infection. At first they discovered
that transient
transfection
yielded low success rates, so they used a PiggyBac
transposon system to insert the gRNAs
into the genome of the PK15 cells.
Two
CRISPR-Cas9
gRNAs to target the catalytic region of the PERV pol
gene.
The two gRNA targeting
sequences are shown below a schematic of PERV gene structure.
Their PAM sequences are
highlighted in red.(Adapted from Yang et
al., 2015)
TAKE HOME MESSAGE
By taking advantage of knowledge about cell pathways,
we can
target certain problems with greater specificity. In this study, the
manipulation of the CRISPR system resulted in the genome-wide inactivation
of
PERVs. Because the strategy Church’s team used also resulted in no
significant
instances of genomic rearrangement, xenotransplantation could potentially
be
the answer to the shortage of organs for transplants without any
repercussions
involving viral transmission.
PERSONAL EVALUATION
The overall research did well in using multiple genomic technologies in analysis and sequence checking as well as testing for in vitro transmission of PERVs with respect to their disruption of PERV pol genes. Future studies in this area should include analysis of other sources of PERV transmission.
CITATIONS:
Glaser, Vicki, Patricia Dimond, Gail Dutton, and
Angelo
DePalma. "CRISPR-Clean
Pig Genome Could Mean Safer Pig-to-Human
Transplants | GEN News Highlights | GEN." GEN. Genengnews,
14 Oct.
2015. Web. 23 Jan. 2016.
Yang, L., M. Guell, D. Niu, H. George, E. Lesha, D.
Grishin,
J. Aach, E. Shrock, W. Xu, J. Poci, R. Cortazio, R. A. Wilkinson, J. A.
Fishman, and G. Church. "Genome-wide
Inactivation of Porcine Endogenous
Retroviruses (PERVs)." Science 350.6264 (2015): 1101-104.
Web.