What is Chimeraplasty?
Chimeraplasty, also known as targeted gene correction, is a technique in which a synthetically created molecule consisting of both RNA and DNA is used to repair single base pair mutations, deletions, or insertions in DNA.
Background InformationThe technique of chimeraplasty was developed in the lab of Drs. Eric B. Kmiec, Kyonggeun Yoon, and Allyson Cole-Strauss, at Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (Gura 1999 ). Kmiec studies homologous recombination, and he realized that the rate of recombination is increased for active genes being transcribed into mRNAs (Gura 1999). This led him to question whether synthetic RNA could be used in gene repair by tricking the cell to incorporate good DNA into mutated sites (Gura 1999). However, the problem with this idea was that RNA degrades much faster than DNA, and might not last long enough to repair the targeted DNA (Gura 1999 ). Finally, Kmiec realized that he could create a hybrid DNA-RNA molecule (a chimeraplast) that would be stable for long enough to allow gene repair (Gura 1999).
StructureA chimeraplast consists of a paper-clip shaped, double-stranded stretch of DNA interspersed with short strands of RNA (Fig. 1) (Stephenson 1999). The design of the chimeraplast is a result of the discovery that hybrids of RNA and DNA are very active in homologous pairing reactions (Cole-Strauss and others 1996; Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996). Furthermore, researchers found that the hairpin caps at the ends of the molecules do not impede base pairing with target genes (Cole-Strauss and others 1996; Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996). The purpose of the short RNA strands is to activate the oligonucleotide ("oligo") for recombination, and the hairpin caps protect the molecule from destabilization or destruction by exonucleases or cellular helicases (Cole-Strauss and others 1996; Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996). Finally, the ribose of the RNA is 2'-O-methyl modified to add protection against cleavage by RNase H activities (Cole-Strauss and others1996; Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996).
DesignWhen researchers design a chimeric oligonucleotide, they replicate a short portion of the base sequence of the target gene surrounding the base pair mutation so that it aligns perfectly with the gene, except for the one base pair where the mutation occurs (Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996 ;Cole-Strauss and others 1999). In this location, the correct base is substituted into the oligo (Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996 ;Cole-Strauss and others 1999). Therefore, when the chimera inserts between the strands of target DNA (Fig. 2), the mismatched base pair is recognized by the endogenous repair system, and the sequence is changed in either the chimeraplast (using the target DNA as a template), or in the target DNA (using the chimera as a template) (Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996 ;Cole-Strauss and others 1999).
Mechanism of Repair
In cell-free extracts, chimeric oligos probably work by pairing with a plasmid target based on homology (Fig. 2), using DNA pairing enzymes and complexes (Cole-Strauss and others 1999). After pairing, endogenous repair machinery recognizes the mismatch between the gene and the chimera, and uses mismatch repair to correct the "spelling mistake" by using the chimera as the template sequence (Fig. 2) (Cole-Strauss and others 1999). Then, the chimera decays, leaving only the corrected target DNA (Fig. 3) (Coghlan 1999).
For in vivo repair, the oligos can be attached to organ-specific ligands, as has been performed by Li-Wen Lai at the University of Arizona in Tucson (Smaglik 2000). Liposomes and synthetic polymers are also used to deliver chimeric molecules to the appropriate cells or tissue (Stephenson 1999). In plants, microscopic gold particles are coated with the chimeric molecules and fired into cells (Coghlan 1999). In all cases, the oligos that enter the nucleus can repair point mutations within the cell after pairing with their sequence-specific target DNA (Fig. 2) by causing the cell's repair machinery to perform mismatch repair on the point mutation (Cole-Strauss and others 1999). After correction, the chimera decays, leaving the corrected gene (Fig. 3) (Coghlan 1999).
Fig. 1. The chimeraplast is a paper-clip shaped, double stranded stretch of DNA interspersed with short strands of RNA (Stephenson 1999). The base sequence of the chimeraplast perfectly matches the sequence of the target gene, except at the location marked with a box ("Mismatched Bases") (Cole-Strauss and others 1996; Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996).
Fig. 2. The chimera integrates itself between the two strands of target DNA, and the hairpin binds to the target gene (Yoon, Cole-Strauss, and Kmiec 1996). Because of the mismatched bases, the endogenous repair mechanisms change the sequence of the target gene, using the chimera as a template (Cole-Strauss and others 1999; Coghlan 1999). This corrects the point mutation in the target gene.
Fig. 3. After correcting the target gene, the hairpin decays, leaving only the corrected target gene (Coghlan 1999).
- Gene Therapy for point mutations: Though not yet used in human subjects, chimeraplasty has the potential to be of amazing benefit in correcting genetic diseases that occur due to a point mutation, such as Sickle Cell Anemia (Cole-Strauss and others 1996) and Crigler-Najjar Syndrome (Gura 1999). Some scientists claim that chimeraplasty could be used to treat up to 80% of human genetic diseases (Robrish 1999).
- Gene Therapy for autosomal dominant mutations: chimeraplasty is more likely to be able to correct autosomal dominant mutations than traditional gene therapy (Stephenson 1999). In the case of a dominant mutation, one mutated gene is sufficient to cause the disease, and the mere adding of a second normal gene may not be able to overcome the "bad" gene. Chimeraplasty avoids this problem by merely correcting the mutated gene, rather than by trying to overpower that gene (Stephenson 1999).
- Agriculture: Dr. Charles Antzen of Cornell University has already shown that chimeraplasty can be used to create tobacco plants resistant to sulphonylurea weed killers by altering the gene for acetolactate synthase so that the tobacco plant does not bind sulphonylurea (Coghlan 1999). Likewise, Dr. Antzen predicts that chimeraplasty could be used to make crops more nutritious by causing mutations that would lead to higher nutrient productions (Coghlan 1999).
- "Knock out" genes: chimeraplasty may serve as a valuable research tool by allowing researchers to "knock out" genes from adult tissues (Stephenson 1999). By creating a "knock out" gene, researchers can study the function of the gene by noting any changes when the gene is non-functional in comparison to a functional gene (Stephenson 1999).
- At this point in time, chimeraplasty can perform only small corrections (up to three consecutive base pairs) in a gene (Stephenson 1999). However, researchers hope that the technique will eventually be able to repair genes effected by larger defects than point mutations (Stephenson 1999).
- One of the main problems encountered with chimeraplasty is a very unpredictable rate of gene correction (Stephenson 1999). Li-Wen Lai, at the University of Arizona at Tucson, has reported variation in conversion between 1% and 40% (Smaglik 2000). Scientists are not sure what causes this large variability, but suspect that delivery of the chimera to the target DNA is very unpredictable (Stephenson 1999).
- Another possible drawback of chimeraplasty is that the chimeric molecule may alter other genes that are closely related to the target gene due to sequence similarity of genes within a family (Stephenson 1999; Cole-Strauss and others 1996). This could cause unwanted, and possibly harmful effects. However, Cole-Strauss and others (1996) showed that accidental pairing did not occur between two genes that were 90% homologous, including 5 identical base pairs over the core targeting sequence.
Coghlan A. 1999. Look, no new genes: A subtle technique tricks plant cells in doing their own genetic engineering. New Scientist 163 (2197): 4.
Cole-Strauss A, Gamper H, Holloman WK, Munoz M, Cheng N, Kmiec EB. 1999. Targeted gene repair directed by the chimeric RNA/DNA oligonucleotide in a mammalian cell-free extract. Nucleic Acids Research 27 (5): 1323-1330.
Cole-Strauss A, Yoon K, Xiang Y, Byrne BC, Rice MC, Gryn J, Holloman WK, Kmiec EB. 1996. Correction of the Mutation Responsible for Sickle Cell Anemia by an RNA-DNA Oligonucleotide. Science 273: 1386-1389.
Gura T. 1999. Repairing the Genome's Spelling Mistakes. Science 285: 316-318.
Robrish D. 1999 July 26. New technique permits faster, more accurate gene tailoring. CNEWS Science. <http://www.caldercup.com/CNEWSScience9907/26_gene.html> Accessed 2000 Feb 20.
Smaglik P. 2000 Jan 10. Chimeraplasty Potential: As research advances, hopes rise, but efficiency and safety are still concerns. The Scientist. <http://www.the-scientist.library.upenn.edu/yr2000/jan/research_000110.html> Accessed 2000 Feb 20.
Stephenson J. 1999. New Method to Repair Faulty Genes Stirs Interest in Chimeraplasty Technique. JAMA 281 (2): 119-121.
Yoon K, Cole-Strauss A, Kmiec EB. 1996. Targeted gene correction of episomal DNA in mammalian cells mediated by chimeric RNA-DNA oligonucleotide. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 93: 2071-2076.
Return to the Molecular Biology Homepage
© Copyright 2000 Department of Biology, Davidson College, Davidson, NC 28036
Send comments, questions, and suggestions to:firstname.lastname@example.org